RRLAResidential Roofing Contractors
Association of Louisiana
← News FORTIFIED ROOFS · National

Shingle makers push back on 15-year roof age cap for Fortified

The IBHS rule starts January 1, 2027, and manufacturers fear insurers will stretch it to all shingle roofs.

By Jonathan Davis, Secretary-Treasurer · November 10, 2026

Home with an asphalt shingle roof (file photo)
Home with an asphalt shingle roof (file photo) Photo: User:Tallguy0187 / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 3.0

Asphalt-roofing manufacturers are objecting to a new Insurance Institute for Business and Home Safety (IBHS) rule that limits the Fortified roof designation to roofs less than 15 years old, Claims Journal reported November 10.

A September 29 IBHS Fortified bulletin says homes with roofs more than 15 years old can no longer earn the designation. The rule takes effect January 1, 2027. IBHS says it applies only to Fortified re-certification and “does not establish asphalt shingle service life.” The bulletin draws on a 10-year study of shingles at IBHS roof farms and on roof examinations after three windstorms.

The Asphalt Roofing Manufacturers Association (ARMA) says the IBHS conclusions rest on nonstandard testing and incomplete modeling. ARMA also says the study leaves out positive performance results and manufacturer installation guidelines. It urges insurers not to use the bulletin for broad underwriting restrictions and calls for consensus-based engineering standards.

A Florida roofing association official told Claims Journal that shingle quality varies widely, and that a roof-age rule would shift costs to homeowners. Roofing groups worry carriers will apply the 15-year logic to all shingle roofs. The article notes Florida, Texas and Virginia have laws limiting roof-age non-renewals. Claims Journal did not mention Louisiana.

IBHS, which is funded by the property and casualty insurance industry, reported in May that more than 100,000 structures were Fortified, roughly double the 2023 count.

What this means for roofers

  • Fortified re-certification on roofs older than 15 years will not be available after January 1, 2027.
  • Watch for carriers citing roof age in underwriting and renewal decisions; document roof condition and installation quality for customers.
  • Ask counsel about how state roof-age rules apply to your customers’ policies.

Sources: Claims Journal